Grid operators across the U.S. recently submitted plans to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission outlining how they will respond to large loads such as data centers.
California ISO
In its filing, the California Independent System Operator said it was submitting the filing to enhance its large load interconnection procedures through a tariff amendment and address the issues the Commission raises in a prior Order to Show Cause.
Taken together, the CAISO and Participating Transmission Owner (PTO) tariff revisions supply the tariff-level clarity, customer protections, and operational tools the Order to Show Cause seeks, the grid operator said. “The result is a comprehensive near-term response to the Order that can accelerate viable large load projects without compromising reliability, affordability, or open access.”
The Commission’s Order asked whether the CAISO tariff remains just and reasonable as unprecedented large load growth tests utility tariffs nationwide, CAISO noted.
CAISO’s proposed reforms “answer the Commission’s concerns through a framework tailored to the CAISO’s distinctive market design and the existing division of responsibility between the CAISO and its PTOs,” the grid operator said.
The CAISO’s proposals “constitute a major step toward enabling the timely development and interconnection of data centers and other new large loads. The concepts proposed rest on a foundation of highly integrated planning and coordination among the CAISO, PTOs, State energy agencies, and local regulatory authorities, and provide a framework upon which the PTOs will layer their own processes to serve new large loads while upholding and reinforcing the CAISO’s commitment to reliability.”
The proposed reforms “strengthen accountability and protect existing customers. They improve transparency, operational visibility, technical standards, cost responsibility, and protection against speculative development,” CAISO said.
First, the CAISO and PTO tariff revisions create streamlined paths for large loads to interconnect to the transmission system while preserving the PTOs’ lead role in connecting and serving load, it noted.
Standardized application information, deposits, milestones, study coordination, and service agreements will make the process more transparent and predictable. A large load threshold and enhanced data requirements will give the CAISO and PTOs earlier visibility into a project’s size, timing, operating profile, and potential system effects. Coordinated studies, technical standards, telemetry, modeling, ride-through, ramping, power-quality, and other operating requirements will allow the CAISO to identify and mitigate reliability impacts before service begins and to operate the grid reliably after the load comes online.
Second, the PTOs will implement just and reasonable deposit, security, reimbursement, and cost-recovery provisions in their own tariffs, CAISO said.
“Milestone and readiness requirements will reduce the risk that speculative projects drive premature investment, and expanded reporting will provide greater transparency into large load requests, study status, projected demand, required upgrades, and cost responsibility. Together, these measures align costs with beneficiaries and cost causers and reduce the risk that abandoned, delayed, or underutilized projects leave other transmission customers paying for facilities built principally to serve a new large load.”
Third, CAISO’s tariff revisions close any gaps presented by co-located and behind-the-meter arrangements, it told FERC.
CAISO clarifies their treatment and requires generator interconnection customers to disclose plans to serve co-located load, enabling CAISO to coordinate its generator studies with the PTOs’ load-interconnection review.
The framework distinguishes service to load from generator interconnection service, preserves applicable transmission charges and reliability obligations, and allocates upgrade costs based on the facilities and service actually required. These provisions give load and generation developers significant flexibility regardless of their planned configuration. The CAISO also has clarified how developers can submit new interconnection requests or modify existing load or generation sites.
Fourth, the CAISO proposes new service options for flexible large loads that can reduce consumption when transmission capability is unavailable. The CAISO’s Flexible Interim Load Interconnection (FILI) can permit earlier energization while network upgrades are pending, enabling the PTOs to provide bespoke solutions to large loads based on their configurations and constraints. Eligibility, study, metering, communications, dispatch, and compliance requirements ensure that flexibility is real and operationally dependable rather than assumed. FILI provides a near-term, prioritized solution for large load developers, with additional work planned on permanent flexibility and other emerging configurations.
PJM Interconnection
The PJM Interconnection proposed tariff revisions that include:
- Revisions to the terms and conditions for Network Integration Transmission Service to impose new terms and conditions on Eligible Customers taking transmission service on behalf of Eligible Load (including specifically Co-Located Load and customers with Behind the Meter Generation and Large Loads;
- Tariff revisions to create a new Fast Energization Process, which will study together New Service Requests, including Generation Interconnection Requests, and requests from Eligible Customers seeking transmission service on behalf of Eligible Load and Large Load in a single, 12-month process;
- Addition of a new Part XI to its Open Access Transmission Tariff, providing the terms and conditions for new transmission services (Interim NITS, Firm Contract Demand (FCD) Transmission Service, and Non-Firm Contract Demand (NFCD) Transmission Service) available to Eligible Customers taking transmission service on behalf of Eligible Load and Large Load; and
- Revised versions of Tariff provisions concerning Co-Located Load and BTMG pending in FERC Docket No. ER26-1479-002, which PJM has reevaluated and revised in connection with its response to FERC’s Order Instituting Proceeding Under Section 206 of the FPA.
PJM said its proposed revisions address the Commission’s areas of concern in the Large Load and Co-Located Load show cause proceedings -- promotion of reliability, efficient transmission service study processes, cost transparency and mitigation of cost-shifting, flexible load service, accommodating Co-Located Loads and BTMG and generation study procedures for generators serving electrically proximate Large Loads and Co-Located Loads.
PJM proposes to add to its Tariff an enhanced process to identify and study transmission service for new Large Loads.
PJM will require Large Loads (i.e., loads over 50 MW at a single location) to be identified on a registry to set a baseline for the current level of transmission service.
PJM will then require any new requests for transmission service or requests to increase existing service beyond the baseline level to apply for that service and be studied.
In evaluating such requests, PJM proposes to use a new, reformed “Fast Energization Process,” to make the study process faster, even more focused on readiness and certainty, and provide enhanced transparency, it said.
The Fast Energization Process proposes key reforms to the existing process to complete studies in 12 months.
PJM said its Fast Energization Process will study requests for transmission service and Generation Interconnection Requests together to optimize the Transmission System and yield efficiencies for electrically proximate load and generation.
PJM also proposes implementing the three new transmission services the Commission put forward in a way that will ensure reliability, with technical and operational limitations on withdrawals of energy by flexible Large Loads and Eligible Loads, and on injections of energy by Eligible Generating Facilities.
“In short, this filing responds in a unified fashion to two separate show cause orders, one that has been ongoing for almost two years, with briefing and several compliance filings required, and a second issued only five months ago, with overlapping concerns and considerations.”
In light of the resulting scope and complexity of this filing, PJM is asking that the Commission establish a 60-day comment period for the filing, to allow all interested parties sufficient time to review the proposed revisions and for PJM to continue to engage with stakeholders after filing to potentially further improve and augment the proposals set forth in this filing.
ISO New England
ISO New England, the New England Power Pool, and the Participating Transmission Owners Administrative Committee jointly filed a proposal with FERC on Nov. 13.
Under the proposal, the ISO would assess the system impact of proposed large loads through a clearly defined application and study process to be implemented June 1, 2027.
The proposal creates three ways in which transmission customers may request transmission service on behalf of large loads:
• Firm contract demand service gives the customer the same priority as all other firm loads. But it requires investment in the form of new capacity and upgrades to the transmission network to support the large load. Under the “bring your own new capacity” requirement, demand from the large load must be matched by new capacity supply.
• Interim contract demand service is a non-firm service available for customers working to meet the requirements for firm service.
• Non-firm contract demand service is a permanent service option that does not require designation of new capacity supply and may require less extensive network upgrades. It is designed for customers with flexible large loads willing to reduce electricity consumption under certain conditions.
The ISO would “re-dispatch” non-firm and interim contract demand service customers anytime energy prices in their area reach $250 per megawatt-hour (MWh). Re-dispatching requires the customer to either reduce consumption or increase eligible generation.
Currently the region crosses the $250/MWh price threshold in only about 1% of hours. Re-dispatching at this price ensures the non-firm customer is instructed to reduce demand prior to reliability risks posed by the customer’s lower level of network upgrades and lack of capacity supply, ISO-NE said.
The proposal also excludes non-firm and interim contract demand service from the calculation used to set the region’s installed capacity requirement (ICR) and related values. ICR represents how much electricity-generating and demand-reducing capability must be procured through the region’s capacity market.
Stakeholder discussions will continue in 2027 on the “bring your own new capacity” requirement, it said.
New York ISO
The New York Independent System Operator submitted proposed revisions to its Open-Access Transmission Tariff and Market Administration and Control Area Services Tariff to establish new Large Load Integration Procedures and related market participation provisions.
The grid operator said the proposals in the filing are designed to account for issues and conditions in the NYISO region. “They build on the NYISO’s recently adopted Standard Interconnection Procedures and on various NYISO-specific independent entity variations that are foundational to the interconnection process in New York and that bring many benefits.”
NYISO said they also:
• Address the unprecedented near-term resource adequacy challenges, driven in large part by an expected influx of large loads, that the NYISO now faces;
• Leverage the NYISO’s existing “financial” transmission reservation service model to maximize the benefits to flexible large loads and other customers; and
• Contain various mechanisms to protect customers.
NYISO said its proposals recognize that NYISO is a single-state entity whose operational boundaries coincide with the retail rate and resource adequacy jurisdiction of the New York State Public Service Commission.
The NYPSC has separately launched a proceeding to address state-jurisdictional interconnection reforms that are likely to influence the evolution of Commission-jurisdictional large load rules in New York, NYISO noted.
NYISO said its proposal incorporates a compromise approach to resource adequacy requirements, the State Exempt Load Project exception, that is intended to reconcile the NYISO’s reliability responsibilities with the NYPSC’s resource adequacy authority in a manner that is consistent with cooperative federalism principles.
“More generally, the NYISO has carefully considered and sought to adhere to the Commission’s guidance on large load jurisdictional issues and to respect both federal and state authority while still producing a proposal that effectively meets the NYISO region’s needs.”
NYISO noted that New York’s Commission-jurisdictional transmission-owning utilities concurrently made separate Federal Power Act Section 205 filings to address Show Cause Order matters that fall under their reserved filing rights.
Midcontinent ISO
In its filing, MISO said that to date it has been able to successfully manage the integration of large loads leveraging existing MISO tools “and quickly recognized the need for additional frameworks and processes to support reliable, efficient, and cost-effective integration given projected trends for faster and dramatic demand growth across the region.”
To this end, MISO, its Transmission Owners, state regulatory authorities, and broad stakeholder community have been working collaboratively to support the reliable, cost-effective, and efficient integration of large loads, it said.
“Over the past two years MISO has been developing new processes and tools to provide additional transparency, efficient reliability standardization, integrated solutions for generation and new transmission service offerings with stakeholders to meet the challenge.”
The MISO Large Load Working Group “has been an effective clearing house for such efforts and is providing a constructive, collaborative forum to develop these solutions. This group met over thirteen times in the last eight months with an average of 400 people and a peak of 1000 people participating in each session. This process included over 100 MISO presentations to stakeholders and over 400 feedback responses from stakeholders.”
MISO said it recognizes the need for balanced solutions to support the diverse interests of stakeholders and state policies across the MISO region.
“While these differing perspectives can make unanimity- difficult to achieve, they contribute to a robust stakeholder process and better-informed outcomes that ultimately drive the enormous value that MISO membership brings to customers in terms of reliability, cost-effectiveness and policy enablement.”
The Commission’s Show Cause Order provided important support for MISO’s ongoing efforts to develop solutions for responsible and reliable integration of large loads, MISO said.
“By identifying specific priorities and encouraging incremental filings as solutions matured, the Commission established a framework that enabled stakeholders and MISO to advance improvements without waiting for a single comprehensive package.”
In response, MISO has already filed several proposals responsive to the Show Cause Order that are currently pending before the Commission, including Zero Injection-GIA, Large Load Interconnection Reliability Requirements, and the Load Additions Resource Study.
“Collectively these filings represent meaningful progress toward more timely, transparent, reliable, and cost-effective large load integration, which appropriately mitigates cost shifts to other Transmission Customers.”
The additional package of solutions in the Nov. 16 filing and a companion filing “complement MISO’s pending Large Load filings and directly address the remaining concerns identified in the Show Cause Order. MISO’s filings, in the aggregate, reflect its compliance with the timelines and scope of the Show Cause Order.”
At the same time, MISO recognizes that Large Load integration will continue to evolve.
“These filings represent an important milestone, not an endpoint. MISO remains committed to further enhancing its planning, operational, and market frameworks as experience is gained and system needs grow. The Large Load Working Group will continue to serve as the primary stakeholder forum for evaluating, developing and refining additional solutions to support ongoing integration of Large Loads across the MISO region.”
MISO said this filing addresses the following elements identified in the Show Cause Order:
• Large Load Project Review (LLPR): The LLPR establishes a comprehensive application and evaluation process to assess the grid impacts associated with Transmission Service needed to serve proposed Large Loads, including required Network Upgrades and associated costs. The LLPR also includes deposits, project milestones, and other safeguards designed to discourage speculative Large Load requests.
• Large Load Transparency Dashboard: The results of the LLPR periodically will be published to provide transparency into the location and estimated costs associated with Large Load facilities in the MISO region, while protecting confidential information.
• Cost Shifting Risk Among Transmission Customers: MISO and the MISO Transmission Owners have developed new Tariff language and pro forma cost recovery agreements designed to ensure that the costs incurred to provide Transmission Service to Large Load Transmission Customers, including the costs of Large Load Upgrades, are born by such customers and thereby avoid unfair cost shifts among Transmission Customers. The agreements leave retail regulatory authorities able to further disaggregate costs as warranted.
• Additional Transmission Services: The new Transmission Services available to Large Loads include Firm Service Step Up and Interim Non-Firm NITS service. These offerings build off existing NITS service and support the timely integration of Large Loads by aligning Transmission Service with a Transmission Customer’s projected buildout and operational needs, while providing flexibility in how Transmission Service is obtained during different stages of development.
